Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits – Summary
Chapter 1: Clues from the Past
Fisher begins by examining historical market cycles, especially the 1929 crash, to highlight that governments often respond to downturns by stimulating the economy through deficit spending and tax cuts. These policies create inflationary pressures. In such an environment, Fisher argues that high-quality equities are superior to bonds as a store of value. For example, government bonds issued after World War II offered low nominal yields that resulted in negative real returns after inflation. Fisher concludes that top-tier stocks, not bonds, preserve long-term purchasing power. He also emphasizes the importance of research and development (R&D): companies that continually innovate tend to grow faster and maintain competitive advantages. The key takeaway is to seek firms with long-term growth opportunities, strong innovation pipelines, and large, expanding markets.
Chapter 2: What “Scuttlebutt” Can Do
This chapter focuses on Fisher’s famous scuttlebutt method, which involves gathering information directly from people close to the business—customers, suppliers, competitors, former employees, and industry experts. Fisher believes that such qualitative, on-the-ground research reveals the real strengths and weaknesses of a company, far beyond what financial reports can show. This approach builds conviction and prevents emotional mistakes caused by relying solely on others’ analysis. Modern interpretation: Investors must complement quantitative models with primary research that evaluates non-financial factors such as customer loyalty, employee morale, and product quality.
Chapter 3: What to Buy – The Fifteen Points
Fisher introduces his famous 15-point qualitative checklist for evaluating companies. These can be grouped into five key categories:
1. Growth & Innovation
- The company should have products or services with long-term growth potential.
- Management must prioritize innovation and new products.
- R&D must be efficient and translate into a steady stream of improvements or breakthroughs.
2. Sales Strength & Margin Protection
- A strong sales and distribution network is essential.
- The company must have healthy profit margins and pricing power.
- It should have a clear path to maintain or expand margins over time.
3. People & Leadership
- Good labor relations and fair employee treatment lead to superior productivity.
- Strong organizational culture and effective executive teamwork are crucial.
- The company must not depend solely on one “star” executive; it requires a deep management bench.
4. Systems, Suppliers & Financial Discipline
- Cost controls and accurate internal accounting should be rigorous.
- The company must hire top talent in specialized areas relevant to its industry.
- It should nurture long-term relationships with suppliers and customers, even at short-term cost.
- Growth should be funded primarily through internal cash flow, not excessive share issuance.
5. Transparency & Ethics
- Management must be candid and willing to share bad news as openly as good news.
- Integrity is essential; executives must act in the long-term interest of shareholders.
These points form a comprehensive framework for identifying businesses with sustainable competitive advantages.
Chapter 4: Applying to Your Own Needs
Fisher stresses that equity investing should be done only with surplus capital—money that is not required for day-to-day needs. He argues that successful investing does not require genius; what matters is discipline, patience, and thorough research. Investors should avoid fads, avoid blindly trusting forecasters, and follow a reliable process such as the 15-point method rather than chasing hot ideas.
Chapter 5: When to Buy
Fisher strongly opposes attempting to time the market based on macroeconomic predictions, which he considers unreliable. Investors should instead focus on company fundamentals. Temporary setbacks or earnings misses may create attractive buying opportunities if the underlying business remains strong. He recommends staggering purchases over time (similar to dollar-cost averaging). He also notes that buying during periods of panic—such as war scares—often yields exceptional long-term gains, as markets typically rebound once fear subsides.
Chapter 6: When to Sell—and When Not To
Fisher is famously reluctant to sell a stock. He suggests selling only in three circumstances:
- The original analysis was wrong.
- The company’s fundamentals have deteriorated, and it no longer meets the 15 criteria.
- A better opportunity arises and you need capital to pursue it.
He warns against selling simply to “break even” or due to short-term market fluctuations. If the company remains strong, the best action is often to hold indefinitely.
Chapter 7: The Hullabaloo About Dividends
Fisher challenges the traditional focus on dividends. He argues that if a company has profitable opportunities for reinvesting its earnings, it should retain capital rather than pay dividends—since reinvestment often creates more value. However, if a company does pay dividends, the policy should be consistent and not unpredictable. Dividends should be viewed as part of a broader capital allocation strategy designed to maximize long-term shareholder value.
Chapter 8: Five Don’ts for Investors
Fisher lists five common mistakes investors should avoid:
- Don’t buy IPOs—they often lack track records and may be priced too aggressively.
- Don’t judge a stock by its exchange listing—great companies may trade in low-volume markets.
- Don’t fall for corporate storytelling—focus on fundamentals.
- Don’t reject great companies because they look expensive—quality often deserves a premium.
- Don’t rely on arbitrary price levels—focus on intrinsic value, not chart points.
Chapter 9: Five More Don’ts for Investors
Fisher adds five additional warnings:
- Don’t over-diversify; a focused portfolio of well-understood companies is superior.
- Don’t sell in panic; fear-driven decisions generally destroy wealth.
- Don’t rely on technical charts to predict the future; fundamentals matter more.
- Don’t avoid great companies due to short-term overvaluation; quality compounds over decades.
- Don’t follow the crowd; independent thinking is essential for superior results.
Chapter 10: How I Find a Growth Stock
Fisher explains his idea-sourcing process. About 20% of ideas come from industry contacts, while 80% come from respected investors. He performs an initial screening through reports and quickly eliminates most candidates. Only a few companies survive to the scuttlebutt stage. He estimates that, out of 250 companies researched, he invests in just one. If a company passes initial checks, he meets management to confirm the investment case before committing capital. This highly selective approach—deep research on a few companies—forms the basis of his outstanding long-term results.
Advanced Takeaways
Throughout the book, Fisher blends growth and value principles. He emphasizes long-term competitive advantages, R&D efficiency, management quality, and organizational culture. He encourages investors to look beyond short-term metrics and focus on a company’s ability to innovate, grow, and sustain superior returns over decades.
His principles remain highly relevant today:
- invest in companies with durable moats,
- gather real-world intelligence beyond financial statements,
- avoid panic and crowd-driven decisions,
- and hold great companies for the long run.
Comments